There’s some discounted fares available from NYC to Bermuda, Barbados and Panama.
For Bermuda, there’s tons of availability between May 2016 and March 2017, including Thanksgiving, Xmas, and New Year’s. The price is $267 for a round trip direct flight on Delta.
For Panama there’s availability in May and June 2016. The price is $283 for a round trip direct flight on United.
For Barbados availability is on for May 2016. The price is $275 for a round trip direct flight on JetBlue.
You can search for best prices on Google Flights and then book directly on the airline’s website or Priceline. These flights usually go for over $400 so they’re good deals.